PDA

View Full Version : England squad for Brazil and Germany friendlies


danpalace07
02-11-2017, 02:11 PM
Good squad with some interesting choices, not least our RLC. I'm sure some will moan at Southgate for whatever reason though.

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/DNodrOyW4AIvoDC.jpg

Stavros 69
02-11-2017, 03:31 PM
Jesse ******* Lingard, what a joke

Kylie_Tracey
02-11-2017, 03:32 PM
Forster dropped rightly

danpalace07
02-11-2017, 03:43 PM
Jesse ******* Lingard, what a joke

effective off the bench for Rags and England

still a wanker though

Hector
02-11-2017, 03:47 PM
For a couple of friendlies it's not a bad squad. I hope he's sets out a team to give it a real go.

Hudds Eagle
02-11-2017, 06:07 PM
Not sure Gomez or RLC would have gotten in if it wasn't for the clubs they play for (Chelsea not us unfortunately in RLC's case) Surely both Cleverly and Cork have done more this season given RLC's injury. Happy for him though. In terms of Gomez how can anybody in that Liverpool defence get near a call up for anyone? The less said about Lingard the better although he's had a couple of decent games. Good to see Abraham and Winks in there, they've both been in good form and it's good to see young players do well. Good squad and I might even be tempted to watch for the first time in god knows how long depending on who he starts.

the digger
02-11-2017, 06:13 PM
Who put the graphics together? Unreadable.

CP-RJW
02-11-2017, 06:13 PM
Not sure Gomez or RLC would have gotten in if it wasn't for the clubs they play for (Chelsea not us unfortunately in RLC's case) Surely both Cleverly and Cork have done more this season given RLC's injury. Happy for him though. In terms of Gomez how can anybody in that Liverpool defence get near a call up for anyone? The less said about Lingard the better although he's had a couple of decent games. Good to see Abraham and Winks in there, they've both been in good form and it's good to see young players do well. Good squad and I might even be tempted to watch for the first time in god knows how long depending on who he starts.
Ain’t just about current form, also about potential. RLC and Gomez are young and have lots of room to improve, Cork and Cleverly on the other hand are average now and won’t get better, and definitely will never be good enough to be anything other than squad filler, so what’s the point in taking them above talented youngsters with room for development?

Hudds Eagle
02-11-2017, 06:25 PM
Ainít just about current form, also about potential. RLC and Gomez are young and have lots of room to improve, Cork and Cleverly on the other hand are average now and wonít get better, and definitely will never be good enough to be anything other than squad filler, so whatís the point in taking them above talented youngsters with room for development?

But that's been the issue for years. How many big club youngsters have been promoted to the senior team when they weren't ready/weren't good enough and did nothing for years (speaking of Cleverly, he was one) Look at someone like Tarkowski at Burnley, 24 years old, loads of potential and arguably been one of, if not the best centre half in the league this year. Same with Mee. As much as I hate to admit it, that c**t Dunk's had a good season at Brighton so far. It's 100% about big club bias just look at what the three who have been called up have in common. There's only really Abraham who's earned it (RLC probably will with more games but he's been injured for half the season and has no goals or assists yet)

CP-RJW
02-11-2017, 06:41 PM
But that's been the issue for years. How many big club youngsters have been promoted to the senior team when they weren't ready/weren't good enough and did nothing for years (speaking of Cleverly, he was one) Look at someone like Tarkowski at Burnley, 24 years old, loads of potential and arguably been one of, if not the best centre half in the league this year. Same with Mee. As much as I hate to admit it, that c**t Dunk's had a good season at Brighton so far. It's 100% about big club bias just look at what the three who have been called up have in common. There's only really Abraham who's earned it (RLC probably will with more games but he's been injured for half the season and has no goals or assists yet)
Ah I agree youngsters from small clubs don’t get enough of a look in COUGH COUGH Wilf. But average players almost 30 like Cleverly and Cork, I don’t see any issue in leaving them out.

jimmy the gent
02-11-2017, 06:45 PM
Jesse Lingard... If he were playing for Stoke, West Brom or Newcastle he'd be nowhere near that side. Sums England up.

Icy
03-11-2017, 11:54 AM
Yup and Ashley Young is an embarrassment.

They really should be getting more of the under 21's involved and developing them, not playing past it wankers.

jimmy the gent
03-11-2017, 11:56 AM
Don't have such a problem with Young, he is consistent and can be played anywhere down the flank. A decent option to have. Lingard will always piss me off as he's nowhere near Zaha and yet along with Oxlaide-Chamberlain, Sterling and Theo Walcott, was regularly picked ahead of him regardless of form. Sums England up. Not been a true meritocracy for years. All egos and player profiles.

EagleSE24
03-11-2017, 12:02 PM
Build the team around the Spurs players. Then hopefully there will be some cohesion to the team.

I always used to wonder why England didn't just play the Arsenal back five in the late 80s/early 90s. I know Stuart Pearce was better individually than Winterburn, Butcher better than Bould etc but they were so well drilled surely it would have made more sense than throwing strangers together...

richdeniro
03-11-2017, 12:03 PM
Jesse Lingard... If he were playing for Stoke, West Brom or Newcastle he'd be nowhere near that side. Sums England up.

Been that way for 10+ years now and the FA/various England managers just don't seem to learn.

Nicky Butt springs to mind, one of the first names in the squad whilst at Manure. Once he joined Newcastle he barely made any squads.

SteveyHawking
03-11-2017, 12:21 PM
Jesse Lingard... If he were playing for Stoke, West Brom or Newcastle he'd be nowhere near any of their sides. Sums England up.

Edited for accuracy. :p

Glazier69
03-11-2017, 01:08 PM
No Wilf??

PALACEWU
03-11-2017, 01:30 PM
No Wilf??

:vader:

Crofty
03-11-2017, 01:39 PM
They really dropped a plum when they turned their noses up at Wilf.

st albans
03-11-2017, 01:44 PM
They really dropped a plum when they turned their noses up at Wilf.

yeah but he doesn't fit the mould of the attributes you need to be an england winger, i.e. kick the ball in front of you and run after it, try to cross it, fail, repeat

Olympian2
03-11-2017, 01:52 PM
No Wilf??

:lux::lux::lux:

Crofty
03-11-2017, 02:04 PM
yeah but he doesn't fit the mould of the attributes you need to be an england winger, i.e. kick the ball in front of you and run after it, try to cross it, fail, repeat

He He :p

Daniel_Nash
03-11-2017, 02:16 PM
Build the team around the Spurs players. Then hopefully there will be some cohesion to the team.

I always used to wonder why England didn't just play the Arsenal back five in the late 80s/early 90s. I know Stuart Pearce was better individually than Winterburn, Butcher better than Bould etc but they were so well drilled surely it would have made more sense than throwing strangers together...

Sure I'm biased, but this has been discussed on the Spurs forums for a while. As they pick a lot of Spurs players, why not use the same system and find players to fit the other positions. If you include Stones/Walker/Sterling as well, that is nearly the starting XI with a similar pattern of play at club level. No need to shoehorn players in like England have been doing for years.

As an aside, glad Loftus-Cheek/Abraham/Gomez are given a try. I just hope they sort out the goalie. Hart isn't up to the task, and while Butland has conceded a lot - as has Pickford - the defence in front for Stoke/Everton has been crap.

Can't believe there is even a debate about Wilshere missing out. He doesn't start for Arsenal often enough and the others do play for their clubs. I don't think Rose should be there for the same reason, although he is coming back from an injury and has been on the bench recently.

gold76
07-11-2017, 11:02 AM
Winks and Kane out

Livermore in

Adlerhorst
07-11-2017, 11:14 AM
Livermore vs Germany :D

switchboard
07-11-2017, 11:32 AM
An England rant ...

It really has the potential to be a decent young England team but any creative ideas are seemingly coached out of them once they put on the England shirt. The first thing they need to do is drop Cahill, Henderson and Hart out of the squad altogether, ghosts of a past England team full of failure and Henderson brings nothing to the table. Having Pep and Pochettino coaching English players is a dream for Southgate who can reap the rewards for their intelligence.

Not Joe Hart

Walker Stones CB Rose

Dier, Winks,

Alli

LW RW

Kane


I know people slag off Lingaard but the 2 wing positions need to be quick and pacey and cause problems, Lingaard/Rashford/Townsend/Sterling/Abraham/Gray/Lookman are about all we have

Lallana should slot in for Dier or Winks against weaker sides when we should be moving forward.

There is enough basic back up to replace Dier/Winks and Alli when needed.

Sturridge should be more than decent enough to pick off smaller teams as back up for Kane.

There aren't many decent hard working young central defenders in this division who deserve a chance to impress Keane and Maguire are about all I can think of.

It would just be nice going into a tournament with a bit of excitement and no real expectation, instead we are going to be treated to Henderson, Shelvey and Livermore passing sideways for 90 minutes as we lose 1-0 to (insert any team)

The main issue going into a tournament is Southgate, I don't buy into him having the intelligence and forward thinking to devise games to take on the best coaches.

switchboard
07-11-2017, 11:33 AM
I should add that in these 2 friendlies we will play relatively well and get 2 decent results out of them, we always do.

Celestial Empire
07-11-2017, 03:11 PM
I should add that in these 2 friendlies we will play relatively well and get 2 decent results out of them, we always do.

Half of your 'picks' have baled-out "injured".
Probably more defections later this week when the others see the growing list of "no-shows".

Stellavista
07-11-2017, 08:14 PM
No Wilf??

At least Southgate has the option to call him up now Sterling is out.
Oh........

Olympian2
07-11-2017, 08:15 PM
I'm taking my 8 year old to the Germany game on Friday - it'll be our 2nd Wembley visit in a week. That squad is so thin, we're taking our boots.

cpfc4evandeva
08-11-2017, 08:49 AM
If Loftus Cheek was on loan at West Brom instead of us, his selection would have been rightly laughed at/criticised on these boards. Other than the first couple of games, he's looked very poor for us. Is he fully fit yet?

gilesy14
08-11-2017, 09:43 AM
An England rant ...

It really has the potential to be a decent young England team but any creative ideas are seemingly coached out of them once they put on the England shirt. The first thing they need to do is drop Cahill, Henderson and Hart out of the squad altogether, ghosts of a past England team full of failure and Henderson brings nothing to the table. Having Pep and Pochettino coaching English players is a dream for Southgate who can reap the rewards for their intelligence.

Not Joe Hart

Walker Stones CB Rose

Dier, Winks,

Alli

LW RW

Kane


I know people slag off Lingaard but the 2 wing positions need to be quick and pacey and cause problems, Lingaard/Rashford/Townsend/Sterling/Abraham/Gray/Lookman are about all we have

Lallana should slot in for Dier or Winks against weaker sides when we should be moving forward.

There is enough basic back up to replace Dier/Winks and Alli when needed.

Sturridge should be more than decent enough to pick off smaller teams as back up for Kane.

There aren't many decent hard working young central defenders in this division who deserve a chance to impress Keane and Maguire are about all I can think of.

It would just be nice going into a tournament with a bit of excitement and no real expectation, instead we are going to be treated to Henderson, Shelvey and Livermore passing sideways for 90 minutes as we lose 1-0 to (insert any team)

The main issue going into a tournament is Southgate, I don't buy into him having the intelligence and forward thinking to devise games to take on the best coaches.

Agree with this. We are at a time where we have 2,3...maybe 4 top class managers working with our players. We really should be reaping the benefit. Pochettino is arguably the best thing that has happened to the England side in the last 10 years. Sadly Southgate strikes me as a wet drip who will not get the best out of this group - he says all the right things as you'd expect from a seemingly intelligent bloke, but he doesn't seem to have the capabilities to put those words into practice.

For me, it's essential we have a plan A & a plan B. The Spurs template is exactly the one I'd be attempting to replicate. Equally at home with 3 a the back or with 4. I'd like to see something like:

Butland
Jones-Stones-Maguire
Walker-Dier-Winks/Wilshere-Rose
Sterling/Rashford-Alli/Lallana
Kane

Butland
Walker-Stones-Maguire/Jones-Rose
Dier-Winks/Wilshere
Sterling-Alli-Rashford
Kane

Firstly, people will say what am I doing including Wilshere in there. A fit Jack Wilshere is EXACTLY what the England team is crying out for. Dier should be 1st choice defensive mid. If you watch Spurs, playing next to Dembele is exactly what makes Dier so effective in that role. He leaves Dier to solely do the defensive work & is constantly looking to drive Tottenham forward. Wilshere is easily the closest player we have to MD. Winks could easily play that role but it's a lot to ask of a player who has played a handful of first team games. The most demoralising thing about watching England recently has been the 2 centre mids being a combo of Henderson & Dier, Henderson & Livermore, etc. All defensively minded & happy to pass the ball sidewards or backwards. We have a lot of the ball but do feck all with it. We need someone next to Dier to connect defence & attack.

Completely agree re Henderson & Cahill - bin them both. Henderson especially. Absolute carthorse who has never performed at international level.

The attacking options we have really are the best I can remember in a long time. All blessed with talent & young - they really could take the international stage by storm. Kane, Alli, Rashford, Sterling are all capable of being world class. Lallana has also arguably been our best player for a couple of years - international football seems to suit him perfectly. But they need a manager to pick a team which allows them to fulfil their potebntial & play with freedom - in Southgate, I sadly don't think that'll be possible.

bubbs11
08-11-2017, 12:36 PM
VAR (Video Assistant Referee), will be used in the Germany game.

Short video here explaining the process.

http://m.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/41912072

Shipp Ahoy!
08-11-2017, 12:45 PM
An England rant ...

It really has the potential to be a decent young England team but any creative ideas are seemingly coached out of them once they put on the England shirt. The first thing they need to do is drop Cahill, Henderson and Hart out of the squad altogether, ghosts of a past England team full of failure and Henderson brings nothing to the table. Having Pep and Pochettino coaching English players is a dream for Southgate who can reap the rewards for their intelligence.

Not Joe Hart

Walker Stones CB Rose

Dier, Winks,

Alli

LW RW

Kane


I know people slag off Lingaard but the 2 wing positions need to be quick and pacey and cause problems, Lingaard/Rashford/Townsend/Sterling/Abraham/Gray/Lookman are about all we have

Lallana should slot in for Dier or Winks against weaker sides when we should be moving forward.

There is enough basic back up to replace Dier/Winks and Alli when needed.

Sturridge should be more than decent enough to pick off smaller teams as back up for Kane.

There aren't many decent hard working young central defenders in this division who deserve a chance to impress Keane and Maguire are about all I can think of.

It would just be nice going into a tournament with a bit of excitement and no real expectation, instead we are going to be treated to Henderson, Shelvey and Livermore passing sideways for 90 minutes as we lose 1-0 to (insert any team)

The main issue going into a tournament is Southgate, I don't buy into him having the intelligence and forward thinking to devise games to take on the best coaches.

I stopped reading after the bit in bold.

GB2506
08-11-2017, 01:37 PM
Agree with this. We are at a time where we have 2,3...maybe 4 top class managers working with our players. We really should be reaping the benefit. Pochettino is arguably the best thing that has happened to the England side in the last 10 years. Sadly Southgate strikes me as a wet drip who will not get the best out of this group - he says all the right things as you'd expect from a seemingly intelligent bloke, but he doesn't seem to have the capabilities to put those words into practice.

For me, it's essential we have a plan A & a plan B. The Spurs template is exactly the one I'd be attempting to replicate. Equally at home with 3 a the back or with 4. I'd like to see something like:

Butland
Jones-Stones-Maguire
Walker-Dier-Winks/Wilshere-Rose
Sterling/Rashford-Alli/Lallana
Kane

Butland
Walker-Stones-Maguire/Jones-Rose
Dier-Winks/Wilshere
Sterling-Alli-Rashford
Kane

Firstly, people will say what am I doing including Wilshere in there. A fit Jack Wilshere is EXACTLY what the England team is crying out for. Dier should be 1st choice defensive mid. If you watch Spurs, playing next to Dembele is exactly what makes Dier so effective in that role. He leaves Dier to solely do the defensive work & is constantly looking to drive Tottenham forward. Wilshere is easily the closest player we have to MD. Winks could easily play that role but it's a lot to ask of a player who has played a handful of first team games. The most demoralising thing about watching England recently has been the 2 centre mids being a combo of Henderson & Dier, Henderson & Livermore, etc. All defensively minded & happy to pass the ball sidewards or backwards. We have a lot of the ball but do feck all with it. We need someone next to Dier to connect defence & attack.

Completely agree re Henderson & Cahill - bin them both. Henderson especially. Absolute carthorse who has never performed at international level.

The attacking options we have really are the best I can remember in a long time. All blessed with talent & young - they really could take the international stage by storm. Kane, Alli, Rashford, Sterling are all capable of being world class. Lallana has also arguably been our best player for a couple of years - international football seems to suit him perfectly. But they need a manager to pick a team which allows them to fulfil their potebntial & play with freedom - in Southgate, I sadly don't think that'll be possible.

Agree with all this. Especially the Henderson and Cahill parts however Southgate is another FA Yes man and wont have the balls to drop either sadly. He also hasn't got the tactical nous to get the better of any of the top coaches.

I would definitely go 3 at the back with players comfortable to go to a 4 if needed.

---------------Butland----------------
-------Jones---Stones---?------------
Walker----Dier-----Winks-------Rose
----------Lallana-------Alli------------
-----------------Kane-----------------

All of those players play in those positions and formation for their clubs. I think Rose is a bit of a weak link and I would argue that Trippier at RWB is a more consistent player than Walker at the moment. I think if Winks gets a full season under his belt then he would certainly have gained enough experience to warrant a starting place, especially if Spurs do well in the Champions League.

Add in the likes of Rashford, Sterling, possibly Gray if he has a good season with Leicester and we have the options to go 4-2-3-1.

Sadly all of the above is irrelevant with the manager we have. As gilsey has said, they need to be allowed to play with freedom to fulfil their potential and sadly Southgate hasn't got a clue.

switchboard
08-11-2017, 01:55 PM
http://www.independent.co.uk/sport/football/premier-league/pep-guardiola-praises-manchester-city-fabian-delph-england-man-adapts-left-back-role-a7976781.html

Delph on the left?

gilesy14
08-11-2017, 01:57 PM
Agree with all this. Especially the Henderson and Cahill parts however Southgate is another FA Yes man and wont have the balls to drop either sadly. He also hasn't got the tactical nous to get the better of any of the top coaches.

I would definitely go 3 at the back with players comfortable to go to a 4 if needed.

---------------Butland----------------
-------Jones---Stones---?------------
Walker----Dier-----Winks-------Rose
----------Lallana-------Alli------------
-----------------Kane-----------------

All of those players play in those positions and formation for their clubs. I think Rose is a bit of a weak link and I would argue that Trippier at RWB is a more consistent player than Walker at the moment. I think if Winks gets a full season under his belt then he would certainly have gained enough experience to warrant a starting place, especially if Spurs do well in the Champions League.

Add in the likes of Rashford, Sterling, possibly Gray if he has a good season with Leicester and we have the options to go 4-2-3-1.

Sadly all of the above is irrelevant with the manager we have. As gilsey has said, they need to be allowed to play with freedom to fulfil their potential and sadly Southgate hasn't got a clue.

Fair shout re Trippier - I've been so impressed with him when I've watched him of late. Has really come on under Pochettino over the last 12 months.

I'm also not entirely convinced by Rose, but I think he's the best of the bunch currently. It's a shame Shaw hasn't kicked on - he had the potential to be top drawer before his awful injury. Talk of him going to Spurs could be the best thing that happens to him.

I sound like a fecking Spurs fan. I hate it. But I just love Pochettino. I think he's the best manager about - the job he's done there is unreal.

Hibernator
09-11-2017, 12:03 AM
Haven't been to an England friendly in a couple of years , nor have I watched one on the box in that time but I will be watching this one just to see the VAR system in action.

Hope it doesn't slow the game down too much as I think It's about time we cracked down on cheating and theatrics. Which can only be good for the game.

Buysakho
09-11-2017, 12:54 AM
We are going to win the World Cup. As long as Kane stays fit I can't see beyond us.

redsox
09-11-2017, 02:55 AM
You are a comedian England will never win anything they cant compete when it really matters

Golf Boy
10-11-2017, 07:02 AM
RLC to start against Germany. The guy that has come in for the most criticism from us gets to play for England. Townsend was picked as well when he was utter dross for us, when Wilf was on fire. Our other two England players recently - Campbell and Kelly. Have i forgotten someone, Mutch perhaps.

Olympian2
10-11-2017, 07:23 AM
RLC to start against Germany. The guy that has come in for the most criticism from us gets to play for England. Townsend was picked as well when he was utter dross for us, when Wilf was on fire. Our other two England players recently - Campbell and Kelly. Have i forgotten someone, Mutch perhaps.

Apart from Puncheon, Hennessy, Ward & Delaney, that is :p:p:p

Golf Boy
10-11-2017, 07:55 AM
Apart from Puncheon, Hennessy, Ward & Delaney, that is :p:p:p

The last gameor two i meant

Olympian2
10-11-2017, 10:07 AM
The last gameor two i meant

Fair enough :p