Discussion: Who will leave the club in January?

[Owngoal]

Originally Posted by Worksop Palace

We’ve all been bleating that Punch wimps out too much for the last 12 months and when he gets stuck right in he’s a thug

Getting rid is based on his not having had a good game in the league for a couple of years and his mistakes costing us points. The fact he is not exactly a role model as captain is not actually relevant. Another fav of our chairman SP so inadequacies are ignored.

[palacemetros]

Originally Posted by Far East Eagle

There are ways to get the same effect without injuring the other player

Had to be sure.

[Thefunkymonk]

Be surprised if anyone leaves on permanent.

Souare and Mutch out on loan.

[wrightchipvcfc]

Originally Posted by bradpitt

We just need to pay Mutch off and get rid that way, similar to what with did with Kebe, another pathetic waster

That's what mutch would want get his money then find himself anouther mug to give him a contract leave him to rot won't help him find new club when no games for few years football is a very small world let's say Burton were going to buy mutch they would phone a few contacts who have been with him at palace managers coaches players ect be interesting to hear what they make of him does not seem that hungry to play football .

[nomad]

Originally Posted by Far East Eagle

Hopefully Puncheon. Thug.

On and off the pitch (the latter allegedlyof course). His tackle on De Bruyne was dreadful and he should be punished by the club imo. I was embarrassed by those idiots who were singing “he is one of our own” after he left De Bruyne in a heap. Get rid of him now.

[IanH]

Originally Posted by bourne man

Punch knew it, stopped it and took one for the team

The problem was that he buggered that up as well as De Bruyne had already played the ball forward and Man City were away. The ref played on - it was Kelly who took one for the team by pulling the bloke back just before he got into the penalty area.

[nomad]

Originally Posted by in-exile

**** the ginger ****...he puts it about...Punch did it for the team and is not a dirty player... Unlike Kyle Walker!

You are a complete tosser based on these remarks. Condoning seriously injuring players as taking one for the team. Presumably your role models are Chopper Harris and Norman Hunter. De Bruyne is a class player and doesn’t scissor kick players. As for Kyle Walker, in his defence he kept Wilf quiet without kicking the s*** out of him as most teams do.

[Essexeagle]

Originally Posted by bourne man

Would have been so palace to miss a pen and then go a goal down on the counter straight after
Punch knew it, stopped it and took one for the team

Well, except he didn't stop it.

[917L]

Originally Posted by Essexeagle

Well, except he didn't stop it.

Been thinking this, Kelly is the one who ensured they didn't score directly from the break, Puncheons foul was too late to stop De Bruyne passing the ball

Obviously IanH beat me to this...

[smileysmith]

dbl post

[smileysmith]

Originally Posted by nomad

You are a complete tosser based on these remarks. Condoning seriously injuring players as taking one for the team. Presumably your role models are Chopper Harris and Norman Hunter. De Bruyne is a class player and doesn’t scissor kick players. As for Kyle Walker, in his defence he kept Wilf quiet without kicking the s*** out of him as most teams do.

No serious injury. Punch simply stopped a break away by necessary means, happens all the time.

To view the link you have to Register or Login

No need for the tosser remarks, are you not Palace or something?

[SJ'sLoveMonkey]

Originally Posted by nomad

You are a complete tosser based on these remarks. Condoning seriously injuring players as taking one for the team. Presumably your role models are Chopper Harris and Norman Hunter. De Bruyne is a class player and doesn’t scissor kick players. As for Kyle Walker, in his defence he kept Wilf quiet without kicking the s*** out of him as most teams do.

[Old Bill]

Originally Posted by nomad

On and off the pitch (the latter allegedlyof course). His tackle on De Bruyne was dreadful and he should be punished by the club imo. I was embarrassed by those idiots who were singing “he is one of our own” after he left De Bruyne in a heap. Get rid of him now.

It was a bad tackle and he shouldn’t have made it. But

1 it wasn’t as bad as it has been made out in the press.
2 he has been out of the team for a long time and had only been on the field for a short while. I think he was trying too hard to make a contribution.

[McpfcS]

Originally Posted by nomad

You are a complete tosser based on these remarks. Condoning seriously injuring players as taking one for the team. Presumably your role models are Chopper Harris and Norman Hunter. De Bruyne is a class player and doesn’t scissor kick players. As for Kyle Walker, in his defence he kept Wilf quiet without kicking the s*** out of him as most teams do.

Get in the Away End pls

[Yoda]

Originally Posted by Far East Eagle

There are ways to get the same effect without injuring the other player

Having watched the replay and seen that Puncheon was standing on the edge of their penalty box but facing towards our big screen, it would have been more useful if he stayed nearer to the half way line to help block any counter attack.

He then could have met De Bruyne from a more favourable angle...and next time he must face the opposition and watch what happens. It’s one thing for a fan not to watch a pen, but unprofessional for a player to do that, not least because he must be alert for a potential rebound.

[Mr Palace]

Originally Posted by Old Bill

It was a bad tackle and he shouldn’t have made it. But

1 it wasn’t as bad as it has been made out in the press.
2 he has been out of the team for a long time and had only been on the field for a short while. I think he was trying too hard to make a contribution.

Spot on. There's a lot of faux outrage over what was just a badly timed tackle from a player who doesn't have a history of doing that. The over reaction is pathetic.

[Shipp Ahoy!]

The only player I can see leaving if we got an offer for him is Mutch... unless we get an offer too good to turn down especially for a player out of contract in the summer.

[Yoda]

Originally Posted by smileysmith

No serious injury. Punch simply stopped a break away by necessary means, happens all the time.

To view the link you have to Register or Login

No need for the tosser remarks, are you not Palace or something?

Is a dangerous foul only deemed so if the player ends up in hospital then?

It’s just chance that De Bruyne’s injury sounds like it’s not as bad as it could have been.

We would all go nuts if Wilf received a challenge like that.

I’m pleased De Bruyne will be OK, he’s a talented guy and, being selfish about it, we might need him to score against other clubs this season, which could help our cause.

[smileysmith]

Originally Posted by Yoda

Is a dangerous foul only deemed so if the player ends up in hospital then?

It’s just chance that De Bruyne’s injury sounds like it’s not as bad as it could have been.

We would all go nuts if Wilf received a challenge like that.

I’m pleased De Bruyne will be OK, he’s a talented guy and, being selfish about it, we might need him to score against other clubs this season, which could help our cause.

Did I say anything about a dangerous foul or not? I was responding to a point about "condoning a serious injury".

[ebyeeckeagle]

Actually, other than Mutch, no one really, unless we have a cast iron guarantee a replacement is coming. Even Lee has a role (not a great one or one he does particularly well).

On the JP tackle, simply cant believe we had so many players standing on and around the box. They nearly caught us on a corner and am I recalling correctly after that we changed the number going directly into the box for corners?