bigend1 |
07-11-2020 07:37 PM |
Quote:
Originally Posted by gilesy14
(Post 15494873)
I just don’t get the argument that he needs more urgency. We’ve had Luka diving in like an idiot for the past 2 seasons, getting booked (usually early on) & then basically taking himself out of the game as he’s walking a tightrope. Give me Jairo’s approach over that everyday of the week.
Yeah, he missed a header - but there are far, far more positives to focus on IMO.
|
But I'm not comparing him to luka though. I haven't. In fact I've used the the comparison of luka getting sent off/booked vs a much more effective but much less booked/sent off jimmy as an example of controlled agreession and I'm sure that was on the bbs.
That's not what I am saying. Urgency or aggression doesn't have to be a lunging tackle or a nasty dig. Again jimmy shows that, hes not nasty just combative.
But by equal measure sitting off and giving time to quality players in the premiership is punished. Jimmy, mccarthy and how cabaye played means quality players KNOW they will have someone on them as soon as they get the ball! They will expect the first touch to be challenged and if not that tackle is coming. That's the difference between a nice touch, a look up for a run, a moment to pick a pass or spot a keeper they can beat... jairo doesn't.
He has a good tackle etc... is excellent at reading the game and his natural quality on the ball. He doesn't however charge in. He doesn't nudge, kick, push, pull, rush, Harry ans just generally be an arse. That's why we haven't replaced cabye. We can't afford to. Jairo COULD be that guy but will he?
Its not unfair criticism . Its because he could, finally be the guy we need. But not doing thar is a big deal.
As I said I'm guilty of continuing my point from previous posts so get it as negative when it's not. Its a big deal though
|