CPFC BBS

CPFC BBS (https://www.cpfc.org/forums/index.php)
-   Questions to CPFC2010 (https://www.cpfc.org/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=52)
-   -   Questions to CPFC2010 ? (https://www.cpfc.org/forums/showthread.php?t=254808)

James 27-08-2014 06:27 PM

The Moderators (and Steve B) have been discussing a change to the format of the Questions forum and this may be a good place to raise the matter for comments and suggestions.

Concerns have been raised about too many questions in the forum drifting off topic, or into general banter. Often the discussions widens into interesting areas which ought to be in the more widely visited GPD.

One suggestion is that when the forum reopens we ask CPFC2010 to be more ruthless in only approving sensible questions which follow the guidelines (so, for example, questions about players' contracts would be unapproved and would not appear - and nor would threads with mere pleasantries, sycophantic congratulations, abuse and/or idle chatter).

Once a question has been opened and a discussion follows, it will be moved/duplicated by one of the Moderators to GPD, where it can develop or sink with the other GPD threads. Of course CPFC2010 could still contribute to such threads, but away from the Questions forum. The original question and answer will remain duplicated in the Questions forum, but closed for further discussion there.

Another suggestion is that we abandon the Questions forum completely, and just ask Steve to pop in to GPD occasionally (as he is doing now) to address questions.

lombardo7 27-08-2014 06:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CPFC2010 (Post 11938383)
One day you will post something that's not taking the piss out of the club and that will really be news.

Simple question though, do I need to follow them for transfer news after today?

Let's see where we are at the end of the season re Pulis, Warnock and any signings that strengthen our squad.

Eagle's Nest 27-08-2014 06:28 PM

Are you having us on? Serious question!

CPFC2010 27-08-2014 06:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by burgess hill 84 (Post 11938398)
Steve, can you explain to me why Neil Warnock is on the Talksport breakfast show tomorrow morning with Alan Brazil on the first day in a new job ,and not at the training ground meeting the players and staff?

Well they do have a phone at the training ground and I assume he'll do the interview before the players arrive for training.

Scrumpy 27-08-2014 06:30 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by James (Post 11938407)
The Moderators (and Steve B) have been discussing a change to the format of the Questions forum and this may be a good place to raise the matter for comments and suggestions.

Concerns have been raised about too many questions in the forum drifting off topic, or into general banter. Often the discussions widens into interesting areas which ought to be in the more widely visited GPD.

One suggestion is that when the forum reopens we ask CPFC2010 to be more ruthless in only approving sensible questions which follow the guidelines (so, for example, questions about players' contracts would be unapproved and would not appear - and nor would threads with mere pleasantries, sycophantic congratulations, abuse and/or idle chatter).

Once a question has been opened and a discussion follows, it will be moved/duplicated by one of the Moderators to GPD, where it can develop or sink with the other GPD threads. Of course CPFC2010 could still contribute to such threads, but away from the Questions forum. The original question and answer will remain duplicated in the Questions forum, but closed for further discussion there.

Think that's the sensible way forward. Before it closed too many questions kept on being re-asked (is that a real word) and threads descending into chit chat. Its privilege enough to have a chairman that answers questions, so it should at least be done sensibly :)

croydonexile 27-08-2014 06:30 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by burgess hill 84 (Post 11938398)
Steve, can you explain to me why Neil Warnock is on the Talksport breakfast show tomorrow morning with Alan Brazil on the first day in a new job ,and not at the training ground meeting the players and staff?

He's doing a quick chat on the phone , not In the studio.

L'kooch 27-08-2014 06:30 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CPFC2010 (Post 11938415)
Well they do have a phone at the training ground and I assume he'll do the interview before the players arrive for training.

lol burnt

Latvian Eagle 27-08-2014 06:31 PM

Steve... I love Neil Warnock. Great appointment! :p Well done.

Always an Eagle 27-08-2014 06:32 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by James (Post 11938407)
The Moderators (and Steve B) have been discussing a change to the format of the Questions forum and this may be a good place to raise the matter for comments and suggestions.

Concerns have been raised about too many questions in the forum drifting off topic, or into general banter. Often the discussions widens into interesting areas which ought to be in the more widely visited GPD.

One suggestion is that when the forum reopens we ask CPFC2010 to be more ruthless in only approving sensible questions which follow the guidelines (so, for example, questions about players' contracts would be unapproved and would not appear - and nor would threads with mere pleasantries, sycophantic congratulations, abuse and/or idle chatter).

Once a question has been opened and a discussion follows, it will be moved/duplicated by one of the Moderators to GPD, where it can develop or sink with the other GPD threads. Of course CPFC2010 could still contribute to such threads, but away from the Questions forum. The original question and answer will remain duplicated in the Questions forum, but closed for further discussion there.

Another suggestion is that we abandon the Questions forum completely, and just ask Steve to pop in to GPD occasionally (as he is doing now) to address questions.

Like the transfer threads- rumour, confirmed etc- could there be similar for 2010 Q.

Ticketing, memberships, Selhurst etc

Just a thought, they could then be moved to the respective forums etc.

croydonexile 27-08-2014 06:32 PM

A serious point although stupidly put has been raised steve.

Was it mis communication that allowed neteller to break the news instead of the club or is that part of the deal with them ?

Ralph 27-08-2014 06:33 PM

Steve can you explain to me why, several years after you took control of the club we still have so many pillocks, idiots and prats still following us?

(ps. This is a joke so please don't neg rep me all you pillocks, idiots and prats).

Stellavista 27-08-2014 06:33 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by James (Post 11938407)
The Moderators (and Steve B) have been discussing a change to the format of the Questions forum and this may be a good place to raise the matter for comments and suggestions.

Concerns have been raised about too many questions in the forum drifting off topic, or into general banter. Often the discussions widens into interesting areas which ought to be in the more widely visited GPD.

One suggestion is that when the forum reopens we ask CPFC2010 to be more ruthless in only approving sensible questions which follow the guidelines (so, for example, questions about players' contracts would be unapproved and would not appear - and nor would threads with mere pleasantries, sycophantic congratulations, abuse and/or idle chatter).

Once a question has been opened and a discussion follows, it will be moved/duplicated by one of the Moderators to GPD, where it can develop or sink with the other GPD threads. Of course CPFC2010 could still contribute to such threads, but away from the Questions forum. The original question and answer will remain duplicated in the Questions forum, but closed for further discussion there.

Another suggestion is that we abandon the Questions forum completely, and just ask Steve to pop in to GPD occasionally (as he is doing now) to address questions.

What a fantastically Soviet solution, comrade Jameski.

burgess hill 84 27-08-2014 06:33 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CPFC2010 (Post 11938415)
Well they do have a phone at the training ground and I assume he'll do the interview before the players arrive for training.

According to Adrian Durham, his on from 7 till 10.

Andrews69 27-08-2014 06:36 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by burgess hill 84 (Post 11938444)
According to Adrian Durham, his on from 7 till 10.

Durham is hardly solid source material....

mexicaneagle 27-08-2014 06:39 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by burgess hill 84 (Post 11938444)
According to Adrian Durham, his on from 7 till 10.

Bloody long interview.

GreatGonzo 27-08-2014 06:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by James (Post 11938407)
The Moderators (and Steve B) have been discussing a change to the format of the Questions forum and this may be a good place to raise the matter for comments and suggestions.

Concerns have been raised about too many questions in the forum drifting off topic, or into general banter. Often the discussions widens into interesting areas which ought to be in the more widely visited GPD.

One suggestion is that when the forum reopens we ask CPFC2010 to be more ruthless in only approving sensible questions which follow the guidelines (so, for example, questions about players' contracts would be unapproved and would not appear - and nor would threads with mere pleasantries, sycophantic congratulations, abuse and/or idle chatter).

Once a question has been opened and a discussion follows, it will be moved/duplicated by one of the Moderators to GPD, where it can develop or sink with the other GPD threads. Of course CPFC2010 could still contribute to such threads, but away from the Questions forum. The original question and answer will remain duplicated in the Questions forum, but closed for further discussion there.

Another suggestion is that we abandon the Questions forum completely, and just ask Steve to pop in to GPD occasionally (as he is doing now) to address questions.

James, as long as the duplicated thread is linked to in the original questions forum so it can be resurrected if needed that makes a lot of sense. That wway both fans and CPFC2010 can get to the discussions they want to continue quickly rather than searching GPD. What distinguishes between a question thread and a discussion though? Anything with more than 10 replies is moved?

mexicaneagle 27-08-2014 06:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by James (Post 11938407)
Once a question has been opened and a discussion follows, it will be moved/duplicated by one of the Moderators to GPD, where it can develop or sink with the other GPD threads. Of course CPFC2010 could still contribute to such threads, but away from the Questions forum. The original question and answer will remain duplicated in the Questions forum, but closed for further discussion there.

I like this option, combined with an encouragement to give the question a category, so that questions and answers go naturally together. I don't ask much but am only really interested in the legit questions and the direct answers from CPFC2010. I fully agree that discussion leading from those answers should be moved to a new thread in GPD.

Pistol Knight 27-08-2014 06:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mexicaneagle (Post 11938466)
Bloody long interview.

will be mainly spend talking about the best fans in the country and saying ey by gum

GreatGonzo 27-08-2014 06:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by burgess hill 84 (Post 11938444)
According to Adrian Durham, his on from 7 till 10.

He is on from 7 untill 10?

Or he is on between 7 and 10?

Windsor_Eagle 27-08-2014 06:45 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by croydonexile (Post 11938436)
A serious point although stupidly put has been raised steve.

Was it mis communication that allowed neteller to break the news instead of the club or is that part of the deal with them ?

Seriously, why does it matter? Does it affect the decisions taken by the club/board? Does it affect us? We hear the news from BBC and Sky a short while before the club announce it anyway. I really don't understand why people cared so much that Neteller got to 'confirm' it minuted before the club did....


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 06:22 PM.

Powered by vBulletin®
Copyright ©2000 - 2022, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.